10 Myths About Social Media Managers That Need to Die Already

Do you still think social media managers spend their time casually scrolling through Instagram?

If yes, you’re about to get a reality check today on the myths about social media managers.

These individuals manage multi-platform strategies, dive into the data that would make your head spin, and constantly pivot to keep up with algorithm changes that happen faster than even a TikTok trend.

There’s actual data showing that 70% of marketing and creative professionals have hit burnout in the past year.

And this isn’t some dramatic exaggeration; it’s cold, hard reality.

So let’s put these misconceptions to bed once and for all, and learn what a social media manager does, once and for.

Here are the biggest myths about social media managers that seriously need to disappear.

Be the Voice of Every Overlooked SMM!

You’ve built brands and handled crises; now it’s your turn to get recognition. Share your story with #JusticeforSocialMediaManagers and inspire others to do the same.

Free 14-Day Trial

Why Are There So Many Myths About Social Media Managers in the First Place?

Let me explain to you first why there are so many myths about social media managers.

Usually, people only see the end result, which is a witty tweet, a viral Reel, or something that blows up, and think that’s too easy.

But you don’t know about what’s happening behind the scenes, such as the countless hours spent researching, planning content calendars, analyzing data, and having strategy sessions.

The “It Looks Easy” Trap

The truth is, most of the work happens behind the scenes.

Trend analysis, managing communities, scheduling content across different platforms, tracking performance, it’s all stuff that goes unnoticed by anyone just scrolling through their feed.

So, they end up thinking it’s all pretty straightforward.

“I Have Instagram, So I Get It”

I’ve heard from many people that they post on their personal accounts all the time, and it’s not that hard.

If you post vacation pictures, that doesn’t mean you can compare it to creating strategy frameworks, diving into audience data, and making sure content aligns with business goals.

Still Not Taken Seriously

A lot of businesses still treat social media like a side project, rather than a core part of their marketing strategy.

That’s the reason why they undervalue the skill and creativity it takes.

The myths about social media managers persist because the results are out there for everyone to see, but the effort behind them stays hidden.

And that’s exactly why people keep underestimating this work.

Featured Article: 20+ Best Social Media Management Tips for 2025

What Are the Most Common Myths That Distort the Role?

Nowadays, we see social media managers almost everywhere.

Still, most people don’t really understand what a social media manager actually does and think it’s just an effortless job of scrolling through social media all day.

So let’s take a moment to bust the myths about social media managers that keep getting in the way of how we view social media managers, and why it’s definitely time to leave these misconceptions behind.

Myth 1: Social Media Managers Just Post Content

This myth always drives me crazy as it’s so surface-level.

Indeed, a social media manager posts the content, but it’s like saying to an author, “Just type the words.”

You need to know that every post is backed by research, strategy, timing analysis, and an understanding of audience psychology.

Before even posting, social media managers have to figure out what format works, what tone resonates, and when to hit the publish button.

Myth 2: Anyone Can Do Social Media

Since everyone uses social media, people think it’s very easy to be a social media manager.

But the reality is something different.

Social media managers don’t just use these platforms; but they also manage them professionally, which we can’t compare to just scrolling.

These people are digging into metrics, building genuine community connections, and ensuring every campaign aligns with business goals.

Myth 3: It’s Not a “Real” Marketing Role

Some companies still treat social media like a nice little bonus, rather than a key marketing channel.

But the reality is that for most brands, social media is where customers show up first.

Social media managers shape how the brand is perceived, generate leads, and drive traffic, just like traditional marketing, but more quickly and with more measurable results.

Myth 4: Social Media Managers Are Online 24/7

Yeah, it’s true that social media never sleeps, but that doesn’t mean you think the people managing it shouldn’t.

Many social media managers use scheduling and automation tools so they’re not stuck answering messages at 2 AM.

The idea that they’re always available is exactly why burnout is such a huge issue in this field.

Myth 5: Virality Is Their Only Measure of Success

There’s no doubt that going viral is definitely exciting for social media managers.

But you can’t think that it’s the end goal. Real success means steady growth, strong engagement, and followers who actually turn into customers.

Virality might be like lightning in a bottle, but strategy is what keeps things running smoothly in the long haul.

Myth 6: They Don’t Need Strategy, Just Trends

For social media managers, jumping on trends is important, and that can definitely grab attention, no argument there.

But it also needs a solid strategy behind it.

Social media managers are busy researching audience behavior, studying competitors, and analyzing what’s actually working before jumping in.

Trends are just tools in the toolbox, not the whole toolbox.

Myth 7: It’s All Fun, Memes, and Vibes

People like humor, fun, and memes, and that definitely helps.

But what you don’t know is behind the curtains, such as deadlines, brand guidelines, approval process, and key metrics to hit.

The job involves writing, designing, reporting, and optimizing. It’s creative, for sure, but it’s also structured and deeply analytical.

Myth 8: Social Media Doesn’t Require Technical Skills

This one’s completely off the mark.

We’re talking ad campaign management, A/B testing, SEO expertise, analytics platforms, understanding algorithms, and tracking paid campaign performance.

It’s not just about being creative; it takes real data fluency to make it all work.

Myth 9: One Person Can Handle It All

Usually, small businesses fall into the trap that one person is enough to handle every platform, every campaign, every report, and every design.

But in reality, this work typically requires a team including designers, copywriters, ad specialists, and analysts.

If you expect one person to do it all, that’s a surefire way to burn them out fast.

Myth 10: Their Work Isn’t Measurable

In fact, social media might just be the most measurable marketing channel out there.

Social media managers track engagement rates, reach, click-throughs, and conversions on a daily basis.

They can show you exactly how content affects visibility and sales.

These myths about social media managers persist because, from the outside, the job seems simple.

But once you dig into what’s actually involved, the research, the strategy, the constant need to adapt, it’s clear this role deserves far more recognition than it gets.

How Do These Myths Hurt the People Behind the Screens?

It’s obvious when a person puts a lot of effort into their work and doesn’t get the recognition they deserve; it really hurts them.

These myths about social media managers not just annoy social media managers but hurt them badly.

Unrealistic Expectations Lead to Burnout

When people don’t really know the truth of what a social media manager does, they expect magic like viral posts every day, sky-high engagement on everything, and responses at 11 PM on a Sunday.

But that’s just not sustainable. It’s burnout in the making.

When you’re always chasing impossible standards, creativity doesn’t just take a hit; it completely crashes.

Emotional Labor That Nobody Talks About

If you think that the role of a social media manager is just posting content, you need to reconsider your thoughts.

They’re managing angry comments, handling trolls, staying calm in the face of public complaints, and keeping the brand’s voice positive, even when they’re running on empty.

That’s real, draining emotional labor, and it often goes completely unrecognized.

Underpaid for Actually Complex Work

Take a look at the daily tasks of a social media manager (data analysis, strategic planning, ad management, content creation, and community building). You’ll realize that this is skilled work that requires real expertise.

But just because most people don’t understand their role, the social media manager’s salary often remains less than the value they bring.

There’s a huge gap between what this job demands and what it’s truly worth.

What Does the Real Work of a Social Media Manager Look Like?

If you really want to know what does a social media manager do, forget the “just posting” stereotype.

Every day, social media managers balance creativity, strategy, and data while representing the brand online.

Here’s what’s actually happening behind those posts you scroll past.

The Strategist

Every piece of content is part of a bigger plan.

Social media managers design campaigns, set clear goals, and decide how the brand should show up on Instagram vs. LinkedIn.

It’s not random, but it’s all carefully calculated.

The Creator and Designer

Social media managers also craft captions that make people stop scrolling, design graphics that match the brand’s vibe, edit videos, and jump on trends, even while making sure everything stays true to the brand.

It’s creative work that has to strike the perfect balance between being on-brand and on-trend.

The Analyst

What most people don’t know is that social media managers are always deep in the data. They track what’s getting engagement, what’s driving clicks, and what’s actually converting.

Then, they use that info to adjust and fine-tune the strategy. It’s a straight-up analysis.

The Community Builder and Crisis Handler

They’re replying to comments, building real relationships with followers, and when things go sideways, they’re the ones stepping in to protect the brand’s reputation, right then and there.

So yes, behind every post, there’s someone managing all these roles. Usually, all at once.

Featured Article: How to Manage Social Media in 2025: Essential Tips & Strategies

How Can Companies and Teams Help End These Myths?

If companies want better results from social media, they need to stop buying into these outdated myths.

It starts with understanding what social media managers truly do and then giving them the support they actually need to succeed.

Here’s how we can make that happen.

Set Realistic Expectations

Social media managers aren’t miracle workers.

Their daily grind involves campaign planning, audience research, content creation, and performance tracking, none of which happens overnight.

And if you’re expecting every post to go viral or thinking they should be online 24/7, that’s neither realistic nor fair.

When companies set clear, achievable goals with proper timelines, managers can focus on building a solid strategy instead of constantly trying to survive impossible pressure.

Provide Proper Resources

I see this all the time, companies expect incredible results but won’t invest in the essentials, no matter if they’re working with in-house staff or hiring a freelance social media manager.

Good social media work requires scheduling tools, analytics platforms, design software, and sometimes even an entire creative team.

Understanding how social media managers actually work means realizing that great content doesn’t just come from hustle and hope.

But it’s built on preparation and having the right resources in place.

Recognize the Strategy Behind the Work

Social media managers aren’t just “posting stuff.”

They’re diving into data, planning content calendars, shaping your entire brand identity online, and driving real engagement that actually converts.

When you involve them in bigger marketing conversations and celebrate their wins, it shifts the way everyone else views the role and the value they bring to the table.

Build Supportive Teams

One person can’t do it all.

Effective social media work demands collaboration between designers, writers, analysts, and strategists.

When companies get this and build solid support systems, that’s when you start to see sustainable, long-term success.

Why Is It Time to Finally Give Social Media Managers the Credit They Deserve?

Social media managers are the unsung heroes behind every viral post, every thoughtful comment, and every thriving online community.

But their strategic impact on brand growth often goes unnoticed. It’s about time that changes.

They’re the Voice of Your Brand

Every post you see, every comment response, every campaign that actually lands, that’s a social media manager translating your brand into something people connect with.

They’re turning abstract ideas into real stories and casual scrollers into loyal customers.

Yet somehow, the skill and strategy behind all that still gets brushed off. That needs to stop.

Their Work Drives Actual Results

What really gets to me is that businesses continue to underestimate what social media managers actually do, even though their work directly impacts the bottom line.

Campaign planning, performance analysis, audience research, and content strategy all drive growth, boost engagement, and, yes, increase revenue.

Recognition Changes Everything

When you genuinely value how social media managers work, everything shifts.

Morale goes up, burnout goes down, and people start innovating instead of just trying to get through the day.

And when your company builds a reputation for respecting this role, you start attracting the kind of talent that makes your competition nervous.

Time to Shift How We Think

Social media management isn’t some side project you hand off to an intern.

It’s core marketing. It’s brand building. It’s about real-time customer relationships. So let’s put the old myths to rest.

Let’s start celebrating the people behind every post that makes you stop scrolling.

Because they’re not “just managing social media,” they’re shaping the entire story people tell about your brand.

Conclusion

So, what does a social media manager do? A lot more than most give them credit for, and it’s time to move past the common myths about social media managers.

They’re not just hitting “post,” they’re strategizing, analyzing data, crafting content that connects, and managing your brand’s personality in real time.

They shape how the world sees your brand, one post at a time.

It’s time to stop treating social media management as entry-level busy work. It’s a powerful marketing role that drives real business results.

When do companies recognize this? They don’t just build stronger teams, they build brands people want to follow, engage with, and buy from.

Turn Your Expertise Into Influence!

Become a Social Champ Brand Ambassador and help educate businesses on what true social media management really means.

Free 14-Day Trial

Frequently Asked Questions